18 Electron Guideline

Introduction to the 18-Electron Rule

The 18-electron rule is fundamental to organometallic chemistry, providing a framework for understanding the stability and reactivity of transition metal complexes. It is analogous to the octet rule in organic and main group chemistry, but it applies to transition metals, which can accommodate up to 18 valence electrons in their s, p, and d orbitals. A complex that adheres to the 18-electron rule typically exhibits high stability because it achieves a "closed-shell" electronic configuration, minimizing its energy.

The importance of the 18-electron rule lies in its predictive power:

  • Stability: Complexes that satisfy the rule are often thermodynamically stable and less reactive.
  • Reactivity: Complexes with fewer than 18 electrons, such as 16-electron species, are often highly reactive and play key roles as intermediates in catalytic cycles.
  • Design: Chemists use the rule to rationalize the structures of known complexes and design new ones with desired properties.

While the 18-electron rule provides a reliable guideline for many complexes, deviations occur due to steric or electronic factors. These exceptions are equally important, as they highlight the versatility and diversity of transition metal chemistry.

Introduction to Electron Counting

Electron counting is a fundamental tool in organometallic chemistry used to predict the stability, geometry, and reactivity of complexes. Transition metals, with their s, p, and d orbitals, can accommodate up to 18 valence electrons, analogous to the octet rule for main group elements. This is known as the 18-electron rule, which states that a complex is most stable when the metal has a full valence shell of 18 electrons.

The rule relies on counting electrons donated by the metal and its ligands. Stable complexes with 18 valence electrons often exhibit low reactivity, while those with fewer electrons (e.g., 16-electron complexes) tend to be more reactive and play important roles in catalysis.

Procedure for Electron Counting

The following steps outline a systematic approach to counting electrons in organometallic complexes:


1. Identify the Metal's Electron Contribution

  • Determine the group number of the metal in the periodic table. This number represents the number of valence electrons the neutral metal contributes.
  • Adjust for the oxidation state of the metal:
    • Subtract the oxidation state from the group number to get the d-electron count.
    • For example, Fe(0) contributes 8 electrons (Group 8), while Fe(II) contributes 6 electrons (Group 8 - 2 = 6).

2. Add Contributions from Ligands

Ligands donate electrons to the metal. The number of electrons donated depends on the type of ligand:

Ligand Electron Contribution
Neutral CO, PR₃ 2 electrons
Anionic halides (Cl⁻) 2 electrons
Cyclopentadienyl (Cp⁻) 6 electrons
NO (linear, neutral) 2 electrons
NO (bent, neutral) 1 electron
Alkyls, hydrides (R⁻, H⁻) 2 electrons
  • Sum up all ligand contributions based on the number and type of ligands present.

3. Total the Electron Count

  • Add the metal’s d-electron count to the total ligand contribution to obtain the valence electron count of the complex.

4. Compare to the 18-Electron Rule

  • If the total is 18 electrons, the complex is expected to be stable.
  • If it deviates, consider steric or electronic factors:
    • 16-electron complexes are common for square planar or unsaturated systems.
    • More than 18 electrons may indicate an unusual bonding mode or hypervalent system.

Example 1: Ferrocene ([Fe(C₅H₅)₂])

  1. Identify the metal and oxidation state:
    • Fe is in Group 8 and is in the +2 oxidation state. It contributes 6 electrons (8 - 2 = 6).
  2. Add ligand contributions:
    • Each cyclopentadienyl (Cp⁻) ligand contributes 6 electrons (as anionic ligands), for a total of 12 electrons.
  3. Total electron count:
    • 6 (Fe²⁺) + 12 (from two Cp⁻ ligands) = 18 electrons.
  4. Conclusion:
    • Ferrocene follows the 18-electron rule and is stable.

Example 2: Vaska’s Complex ([IrCl(CO)(PPh₃)₂])

  1. Identify the metal and oxidation state:
    • Ir is in Group 9 and is in the +1 oxidation state. It contributes 8 electrons (9 - 1 = 8).
  2. Add ligand contributions:
    • CO contributes 2 electrons.
    • Cl⁻ contributes 2 electrons.
    • Each PPh₃ ligand contributes 2 electrons, for a total of 4 electrons.
  3. Total electron count:
    • 8 (Ir⁺) + 2 (CO) + 2 (Cl⁻) + 4 (PPh₃ ligands) = 16 electrons.
  4. Conclusion:
    • Vaska’s complex does not follow the 18-electron rule but is stable due to steric factors and π-backbonding.